Jump to content

postscript

  • entries
    5
  • comments
    30
  • views
    1,130

society's standards ruin everything and your girl is sick of it


society's standards ruin everything and your girl is sick of it

hi, hpft. it's been a while, but your resident ratTM hath returned from the dead (or: twitter) to hash out some of my inner dialogue once again. today's topic: the toxic environment we've created for teenage girls. bit o' light reading for your commute, you see ;)

what spurred me to write about this? well, my little sister: twelve years old now and in her first year of secondary. secondary is a big change from primary school and though it's been a few years since i was there, i still remember the culture shock from year six (you know, when you were convinced you were the Coolest Person Ever since you ruled primary school and all that jazz) to diving into secondary school more or less blind just a summer later. our local one is a bit... rougher than some (although it's improved since i left) so that adds to the pressure again. as an older sister, i've tried to guide her the best i can, but there's only so much you can do, especially since i'm not at school to guide her like our big sister was with me. and as my little sister - let's call her... strawberry (get it? because i'm plums ? ) - navigates her way through teenagehood, i've come to realise a lot of things i really don't like about the mindset she's being conditioned into.

number one: the pressure to be 'pretty'. sometimes strawberry will talk about friends she's made in school and she'll add in a little line like she's so pretty, you don't understand which is a fairly valid (and nice) thing to say. but then later if i compliment her, she outright refuses to believe me. if i'm going through my phone and i find a picture of her and melt over how cute she is, y'know bc she is literally my baby sister, she says i'm lying. or that i'm just saying that because i have to since she's my little sister. and i'm like ?? in what world. like. why. she flat-out refuses to accept any compliments about herself.

number two: the need to be 'skinny'. listen, i'm someone who struggles with confidence about my weight too. it was worse when i was younger, but i've learnt not to measure my worth in how much i weigh on a scale (i don't use one anymore) and i'm still learning to accept myself. i don't want strawberry to get to the stage where she has to learn how to accept herself. but she's already saying things like "when i lose weight, i'll have to..." or "does this make me look fat?" and i cannot put it into words how much i hate it. the other day, i discovered that she had started a DIET BOOK. SHE IS TWELVE AND SHE HAD A DIET BOOK. i can't put it into words how wrong that is. there is absolutely nothing wrong with wanting to fix up your diet so you're consuming less, say, crisps and more fruit - but monitoring what you eat?? that's exactly what i was doing when i was fourteen and literally so obsessed with my weight i felt like i couldn't sit down for fear of putting on more pounds. and no matter how many times i approach the subject with her, i can't help but feel like i'm getting nowhere.

number three: social media galore. i understand that social media is such a huge part of the world we're in and that kids have more or less always had it around. but i hate how easily it can be weaponised for cyber-bullying, especially with things like snapchat where messages can disappear in the blink of an eye. this isn't a sudden and new problem, but just being on the other side of secondary school really makes you realise how people can get swept up in all that. there's a pressure to be plastered all over social media when you're younger. to have more friends than other people, to have loads of views on your snapchat stories, to rack up likes. and the influencers on these platforms glamourise impossible aspirations, making their livings off of presenting their lives as perfect. while i think that social media has many benefits (it is, after all, how i keep in contact with everyone here), i also think it can be really damaging to someone when they're growing up. it reduces their worth to arbitrary and ultimately meaningless measures.

these are just some of the problems that i think are pretty toxic for all teenagers, not just teen girls even if they're the demographic i'm focusing on. i just really hate how society as a whole has reduced the value of women to their physical attributes, whether this is through social media or through the conditioning of people all around us. as much as i hate it, i know that strawberry is being directly influenced by the older female figures in her life: my mum, who panics once she goes over eight stones on the scale, and my sister who frequently calls herself fat despite going to the gym four times a week and averaging a size 6/8. it's the thoughtless comments of so-and-so is pretty but her sister is prettier instead of saying hey did you know suchabody was accepted into cambridge, she's doing really well with her life. it's how media seems to thrive off the male gaze, off expecting girls to smile like this and be this skinny and behave exactly like this.

it's damaging.

and for all my anger and awareness of the problem these past few years, it never really hit me how hard this bothers me until it affected someone i have an innate desire to protect. i don't want to see strawberry turn from this quirky, cheerful girl who was never too self-conscious for anything into someone who is self-conscious about everything. why should she have to go through all that? quite frankly, i'm sick and tired of society's bullshit standards. i look forward to the day they crumble.

  • Like 6

8 Comments


Recommended Comments

UnluckyStar57

Posted

Amen and amen. I'm sorry that these toxic things are affecting your sister--gosh, I remember going through that stuff too, and it majorly sucks. (I still have to realign my thinking now, even though I'm well past my teenage years.)

I really hate that strawberry already has her hands on a diet book. :/ I hope, for both of your sakes, that it's at least a book that encourages a well-rounded diet, and not a crazy fad diet. Either way, that's not a fun thing to get into when you're twelve--to me, that's still the age of chocolate milk and chicken nuggets, and pizza day in the school cafeteria.

One thing I like about social media, though, is that amidst all the influensters and the posing and the lip kits, there's a corner of the internet (particularly Instagram) devoted to body positivity and being content with who you are. When my friends and I are having bad self-image days, we tend to DM each other body positive posts. (It's the most wholesome thing in my life at this point, hahaha.) I don't know if that corner of Instagram would help strawberry realize that the things she's worried about are not things that define her self-worth, but posts like that are good reminders for me to get out of my own head, personally.

I hope that strawberry can weather the storms of teenage girlhood. And I also advocate for the crumbling of society's toxic female beauty standard nonsense. It's past time for that to end. ?

  • Like 2
dirigibleplums

Posted

2 hours ago, UnluckyStar57 said:

When my friends and I are having bad self-image days, we tend to DM each other body positive posts. (It's the most wholesome thing in my life at this point, hahaha.)

aw that's actually really sweet and a great idea! i'm hoping that i can introduce her to more corners of social media like that so that she can be more comfortable in her body and doesn't feel like she has to warp herself in order to be validated. body image is the worst thing to struggle with imho because your body is... well, you. so i'm hoping to nip it in the bud before it progresses to anything i went through. i hope you (and strawberry and i) can come to a point where we don't have bad image days anymore ??

  • Like 2
magemadi

Posted (edited)

I feel for you so much in this situation Plums, even though I don't have younger siblings (#triplet). ❤️ It sucks that she doesn't have you there to guide her like you had with your older sister, but I think once she realizes all you're trying to do is really just be a good big sister and negate the negativity your mom may be exuding (even if unintentionally) she will appreciate you all the more for it. :hug: 

Social media is definitely much more toxic than it was when first started using it when I was 13-14 (~10 years ago). Something I've started doing in order to limit my FOMO and other bad thoughts regarding others' social lives is to set a time limit for how much social media I get to use for the day using the Screen Time feature on my iPhone (I think you can do something similar on androids?). My friend also has a specific limit of 30 minutes a day for Instagram, which she said has really helped her mindset and also minimizes her distracted scrolling throughout the day. 

My body image issues stem from constantly being called "anorexic" and "too skinny" when I was younger (and occasionally throughout high school and into undergrad as well) so it's kind of the opposite of what's happening with your sister, but I totally get it. ❤️ Being told that I needed to "put some meat on those bones" or "eat a burger" multiple times a day has definitely still influenced my thinking of my body today as an adult, and I'm slowly working on mental positivity, even though I know that I'm perfectly healthy. Also, as my sister is a much more prolific makeup-wearer than I am, my mother actually told me last year that I need to start wearing more makeup in order to do better in professional life and that honestly took me so long to unpack and not start micro-analyzing every "imperfection" in my face. 

Is your sister starting to get into makeup as well? I'm not sure how the change from primary to secondary school translates to the US public school system, but I know that middle school is double rough when makeup is involved. And nowadays, with what seems like every girl and their cousin having a makeup youtube channel, the pressure to look flawless at school is only increasing, and increasing for younger and younger girls. Teenage girls are some of the harshest people out there, and when they've got the internet at their fingertips and disposal, they don't hold back. They not only promote this "perfect" life they're living, but they also are ruthless towards classmates online because they can hide behind the screen and say things they would never tell people to their faces. I hope you can work with your sister on these types of behaviors and lines of thought so her teenage years go much more smoothly than I'm sure many of ours did. ?

Edited by MadiMalfoy
  • Like 2
sunshine_locks

Posted (edited)

I'm really sorry that your sister is unfortunately learning the toxic ways of society. It's a hell of a cycle to break out of once you get yourself in. 

I used to struggle with my weight a lot too, and well, it's a bit more muted these days, but there are just some things I can't imagine happening to me because the thoughts have had such a lasting effect on me. 

I think what really helped me was finding a good support system, as well as having a hobby to keep you occupied when your friends can't be there for you. I hope your sister finds that.

Edited by sunshine_locks
  • Like 1
dirigibleplums

Posted

@MadiMalfoy even if your situation is the opposite to what's happening with my sister, you should not have had to go through that. i just don't understand why people have to critique other people's appearances when it literally affects them in no way and i'm sorry you had to go through that. i wish you all the best with viewing yourself more positively and hope you get there ♡♡♡

15 hours ago, MadiMalfoy said:

Is your sister starting to get into makeup as well? I'm not sure how the change from primary to secondary school translates to the US public school system, but I know that middle school is double rough when makeup is involved.

i forgot to mention this but she is (or at least trying to be). my sisters tend to wear a full face everyday whereas the most effort i make is lipstick and i can see her thinking that it's the route to go, but we're trying to steer her away from it. it's easier because technically makeup is banned for years 7-9 in her school so she couldn't wear much even if she wanted to. it's something we're pretty firm about, especially bc one of my sisters only wears makeup bc she's very insecure about her acne and is trying to wean herself off it. so hopefully it won't be too much of a problem with strawberry :)

15 hours ago, sunshine_locks said:

I think what really helped me was finding a good support system, as well as having a hobby to keep you occupied when your friends can't be there for you. I hope your sister finds that.

this is actually a really good idea because i... can't think of a hobby she has other than reading. she attempted netball for a bit but gave up on it, so mostly spends time on her phone :/ i'm definitely going to try to get her to do something more active that she loves to keep her more occupied

and i wish all the best for you too ??

  • Like 2
crowsb4bros

Posted

I really, really feel for what you're talking about. We had this issue with my niece right as she started middle school (think 10-11) and it was so heartbreaking. Her "best friend" told her she was too chubby to wear a two-piece swim suit and told her she shouldn't be wearing leggings. My niece is tall her for her age, but that's about it anyway (not that it matters) and suddenly she wouldn't eat at all and it was a nightmare. It doesn't help that my brother had a tendency to talk about women pretty negatively if they didn't fit his appearance preferences. It was a good wake up call for him, but we all had to work together as a family just to get her to eat normally again. I took off work/school for two weeks and spent it with her and we went and got chinese food and pizza and went to the gym together and shopped for clothes to boost her confidence a bit. It's not a solution by any means, but I think sometimes the best thing we can do as sisters (or aunts) is to just constantly push against that nonsense and soothe the insecurities when they pop up. Like everyone else, I hope Strawberry finds the acceptance she deserves and grants it to herself. 

  • Like 4
dirigibleplums

Posted

On 3/18/2019 at 7:21 PM, PaulaTheProkaryote said:

I really, really feel for what you're talking about. We had this issue with my niece right as she started middle school (think 10-11) and it was so heartbreaking. Her "best friend" told her she was too chubby to wear a two-piece swim suit and told her she shouldn't be wearing leggings.

omg what. is it possible to throw hands with a 11yo. asking for a friend :whistling:

in all honesty though, it really is such a frustrating place to be in as an older sister/auntie because as much as you want to deal with the problem yourself, it really is a case of just being there for them to help them move beyond these insecurities if you know what i mean? like it's not a tangible problem, it's mostly in the head so it can feel a bit hopeless sometimes :(

i'm glad your niece has such an awesome auntie like you to help her out! and i hope she is/gets better <33

  • Like 1
Veritaserum27

Posted

Mom of 14-yo daughter here, with some thoughts on this.

Body image has been something that has plagued me since I was probably the age of your sister, plums.  So when I had a little pink bundle in my arms the LAST thing I wanted was to have her go through the same, life-long struggle.  Here are few things I've done to help achieve this:

  1. I made a commitment to never, EVER comment on my own weight/body insecurities in front of her.  I've never said "Does this make me look fat?" or "Ugh!  I need to lose 10 pounds!" or "I HATE my (insert body part here)."  This was not easy to do, because I'd done it all my life... in front of my friends, my sister, my husband.  I've been even more diligent about what I say about myself since she's become a little more self-aware.  The super-cool part about this tactic is that I feel like it has actually benefitted me as much as her!  Because I'm "not allowed" to put myself down, I've probably got the most positive mindset about my own body that I've ever had in my life!  I recommend this to anyone (you don't need to have a young person in your life to do this - haha).
    1. *As a side note to this, there is research to show that the NUMBER one factor influencing if a young girl is good at math is if her mother has told her that she (the mom) was good or bad at math.  As soon as mom says, "yeah, I was never good at math, either," the kid's grades go down!  For this reason also, I've never told any of my kids which subjects I liked or hated in school.
  2. I do not praise her on qualities or attributes that are innate, but rather I focus on giving positive reinforcement on her behavior/actions.  What I mean is, of COURSE I think she's beautiful and smart.  But those are things that people don't have control over.  The idea of beauty being perfection is shoved down the throats of young girls, at every turn.  It is definitely easier to accomplish this through social media, but this isn't a new problem.  Someone gave me the best parenting advice years ago when they said, "Don't ever tell your kid 'Good job - you're so smart,' instead say 'Wow - you worked really hard on that.'"  Working hard is something everyone can do.  Putting forth their best effort is a great skill to learn.  Also, telling a kid how smart they are can cause a lot of stress and anxiety later on, from putting so much pressure on themselves.
  3. Sometimes, I have to let her struggle.  This really goes against most of human nature, but it isn't beneficial for me to 'fix' everything for my kids.  It tears me apart to see them down, miserable, and upset, BUT by letting them sort it out themselves, good things happen.  First off, they gain the skills they will invariably need to get through other tough times in life.  Secondly, if I step in to make it all better, that's sending a message that I think they can't handle it on their own.  They take a hit to their self-confidence, and next time they feel upset or are struggling, they think they need someone else to fix it. This is CLEARLY situational, of course.  There are many, MANY times that kids will definitely need to ask for help and I give it to them!  That's the tricky part about being a parent - you have to make the determination of when it's best to step in, and when they need to feel uncomfortable enough so that they learn from experience!

I hope this didn't come off as too preachy - I didn't intend for it to be that at all.  And though this is my advice, nothing every works out perfectly.  It's all one great-big experiment and I am daily looking for new and creative solutions.  :wub: 

  • Like 1
Guest
Add a comment...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...